Have you ever seen what looks like a passageway between the inside and outside of a geode and wondered what is was?
I love the colors and swirls of this geode and the way it shows the passage. It reminds me of the art work by Judy Chicago called "The Dinner Party".
|Photo Credit, Dave Kleesattle.|
From the few I've seen, I always assumed the material was flowing in through the passage and coating the inside of the empty geode. Then I heard a different theory.
ONE FASCINATING OPINION
His theory was that the channels were formed when the crystals formed inside the geode, thereby creating pressure on its walls. Then at a weak point on the wall, the pressure created an exit, reducing the inner pressure to a manageable level.
I understood where he was coming from, but that didn't explain situations like the one in this image below where you can plainly see that at some time, horizontal layers formed inside the geode. I was perplexed.
|Photo courtesy of Dave Kleesattle.|
TIME TO CALL IN THE EXPERT!
To find the definitive answer to what the passages sometimes seen in geodes do, I called on Brad L. Cross, co-author of Geodes Nature's Treasures (Gem Guides Books, 2006)
He wrote, "It appears you have run into the same perplexing question that all of us “students of agates” have encountered, “Are these mysterious features we see in agates (and some geodes) an entrance or exit channel?” I’ve been a serious agate collector/student for 45 years now and Donna, I simply don’t have a solid answer to your question. I might add that I am far more than an “armchair collector,” I’ve conducted a tremendous amount of field research on various agate deposits and I find nothing that provides a concrete answer.
|Photo credit: Dave Kleesattle|
My personal opinion is that we are likely seeing both entrance and exit channels. One of the things that us agate students must always remember when we are looking at these features is that we are only seeing a surface or two-dimensional view. The question arises,“What is the geometry of that tube deeper into the agate?” While the view we have in hand shows the tube not reaching the outer rim or edge of the agate, it may very well reach the surface several millimeters deeper in the agate and we are simply not seeing it in the view we have in hand.
"I can assure you of one thing – the question of whether these are entrance or exit channels will continue until the end of time. We do not have a solid answer today and unfortunately we’re not going to have an answer when you and I leave this ole earth. Very little solid science or research has been conducted on agates – primarily because they have no economic value to industry. No one wants to sink money into expensive research when there is no monetary return for their investment dollar. That’s primarily why we have no solid answers today on these unusual features.
|Photo credit: Dave Kleesattle|
I'd like to thank Brad and Dave for the help they gave me with this blog post. Obviously, this is a fascinating topic, and barring amazing money for research on this topic, Brad's explanation is the best we'll ever have.
I purchased Brad's "Geodes: Nature's Treasures" at a rock show. While it doesn't discuss the channels I've been exploring in this edition of my blog, it is a comprehensive guide to all things relating to geodes. The pictures of remarkable geodes like I've never seen before are well worth the price of the book alone.
If you're interested, contact GEM GUIDES BOOKS at www.gemguidesbooks.com or order them on Amazon.com
Until next time, when I'm writing about The Unnatural Life of Created Cabochon Material,
Your Lapidary Whisperer,
Karen A Brzys discusses agate formation in detail in her book "Agates: Inside Out". The consensus conclusion of the scientist she researched is that they are influx channels. For me the escape channel theory does not explain water levels, crystal lined geodes with agate outer layers, nor the color layering (why would they be so variable if all the silica fluid was inside the space at the same time?).ReplyDelete